Creative Commons Question
I received the following email from our copyright office today. My initial thought is he can’t use it in the journal article, but I want to confirm this. Thank you. Hi Heather, A researcher with Geological Sciences named Jamal came in the other day to ask Kate some questions about a paper he would like to publish. We aren’t certain, but we think he wants to publish in a traditional (i.e., not open) geology journal. He has pictures from five different sources he would like to include. Four are third-party images from already published books are journal article. The last image is a creative commons image<http://ba.e-pics.ethz.ch/latelogin.jspx?records=:579552&r=1523389539059#1523389548982_1> with a CC BY-SA 4.0<https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/> licence. Because it is a CC share-alike licence, Kate would like to confirm with you if Jamal can use the image in the article if the entire article cannot be licenced CC BY-SA 4.0. Can the article be published with only the one image maintaining the CC BY-SA 4.0 license, and the rest of the article have the standard “all rights reserved” copyright protection? Thanks! Shelby Heather M. Ross (B.A., B.Ed., M.Ed.) Educational Developer (Digital Pedagogies) Gwenna Moss Centre for Teaching and Learning Research Fellow Open Education Group Room 50.5, Murray Building University of Saskatchewan Tel: 306.966.5327 email: heather.ross(a)usask.ca<mailto:heather.ross(a)usask.ca> http://teaching.usask.ca/index.php Find open textbooks and other open educational resources on: http://open.usask.ca
Big smile on my face from the irony of this take but not give scenario. Maybe the researcher’s grant will pay for gold open access with the target journal a la Tri-Council practice. D // David Porter, Ed.D. CEO eCampusOntario 416.569.8707 [eCampusOntario] 211 Yonge St. 2nd Floor Toronto, ON, M5B 1M4 ecampusontario.ca<http://ecampusontario.ca> On Apr 10, 2018, at 4:59 PM, Ross, Heather <heather.ross(a)usask.ca<mailto:heather.ross(a)usask.ca>> wrote: I received the following email from our copyright office today. My initial thought is he can’t use it in the journal article, but I want to confirm this. Thank you. Hi Heather, A researcher with Geological Sciences named Jamal came in the other day to ask Kate some questions about a paper he would like to publish. We aren’t certain, but we think he wants to publish in a traditional (i.e., not open) geology journal. He has pictures from five different sources he would like to include. Four are third-party images from already published books are journal article. The last image is a creative commons image<http://ba.e-pics.ethz.ch/latelogin.jspx?records=:579552&r=1523389539059#1523389548982_1> with a CC BY-SA 4.0<https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/> licence. Because it is a CC share-alike licence, Kate would like to confirm with you if Jamal can use the image in the article if the entire article cannot be licenced CC BY-SA 4.0. Can the article be published with only the one image maintaining the CC BY-SA 4.0 license, and the rest of the article have the standard “all rights reserved” copyright protection? Thanks! Shelby Heather M. Ross (B.A., B.Ed., M.Ed.) Educational Developer (Digital Pedagogies) Gwenna Moss Centre for Teaching and Learning Research Fellow Open Education Group Room 50.5, Murray Building University of Saskatchewan Tel: 306.966.5327 email: heather.ross(a)usask.ca<mailto:heather.ross(a)usask.ca> http://teaching.usask.ca/index.php Find open textbooks and other open educational resources on: http://open.usask.ca _______________________________________________ Canadaoer mailing list Canadaoer(a)mail.bccampus.ca<mailto:Canadaoer(a)mail.bccampus.ca> http://lists.bccampus.ca/mailman/listinfo/canadaoer
Hi Heather The SA only kicks in if a derivative is made. The work has to be meaningful altered. If he's using the images as it - He can mark the image as CC BY-SA 4.0 with attribution and not impact his copyright Kelsey On Tue, 10 Apr 2018 at 16:59 Ross, Heather <heather.ross(a)usask.ca> wrote:
I received the following email from our copyright office today. My initial thought is he can’t use it in the journal article, but I want to confirm this. Thank you.
Hi Heather,
A researcher with Geological Sciences named Jamal came in the other day to ask Kate some questions about a paper he would like to publish. We aren’t certain, but we think he wants to publish in a traditional (i.e., not open) geology journal. He has pictures from five different sources he would like to include. Four are third-party images from already published books are journal article. The last image is a creative commons image <http://ba.e-pics.ethz.ch/latelogin.jspx?records=:579552&r=1523389539059#1523389548982_1> with a CC BY-SA 4.0 <https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/> licence.
Because it is a CC share-alike licence, Kate would like to confirm with you if Jamal can use the image in the article if the entire article cannot be licenced CC BY-SA 4.0. Can the article be published with only the one image maintaining the CC BY-SA 4.0 license, and the rest of the article have the standard “all rights reserved” copyright protection?
Thanks! Shelby
Heather M. Ross (B.A., B.Ed., M.Ed.) Educational Developer (Digital Pedagogies) Gwenna Moss Centre for Teaching and Learning
Research Fellow Open Education Group
Room 50.5, Murray Building University of Saskatchewan Tel: 306.966.5327 <(306)%20966-5327> email: heather.ross(a)usask.ca <heather.ross(a)usask.ca> http://teaching.usask.ca/index.php
Find open textbooks and other open educational resources on: http://open.usask.ca
_______________________________________________ Canadaoer mailing list Canadaoer(a)mail.bccampus.ca http://lists.bccampus.ca/mailman/listinfo/canadaoer
Thanks Kelsey. Heather M. Ross (B.A., B.Ed., M.Ed.) Educational Developer (Digital Pedagogies) Gwenna Moss Centre for Teaching and Learning Research Fellow Open Education Group Room 50.5, Murray Building University of Saskatchewan Tel: 306.966.5327 email: heather.ross(a)usask.ca<mailto:heather.ross(a)usask.ca> http://teaching.usask.ca/index.php Find open textbooks and other open educational resources on: http://open.usask.ca On Apr 10, 2018, at 3:06 PM, Kelsey Merkley <kelsey(a)uncommonwomen.org<mailto:kelsey(a)uncommonwomen.org>> wrote: Hi Heather The SA only kicks in if a derivative is made. The work has to be meaningful altered. If he's using the images as it - He can mark the image as CC BY-SA 4.0 with attribution and not impact his copyright Kelsey On Tue, 10 Apr 2018 at 16:59 Ross, Heather <heather.ross(a)usask.ca<mailto:heather.ross(a)usask.ca>> wrote: I received the following email from our copyright office today. My initial thought is he can’t use it in the journal article, but I want to confirm this. Thank you. Hi Heather, A researcher with Geological Sciences named Jamal came in the other day to ask Kate some questions about a paper he would like to publish. We aren’t certain, but we think he wants to publish in a traditional (i.e., not open) geology journal. He has pictures from five different sources he would like to include. Four are third-party images from already published books are journal article. The last image is a creative commons image<http://ba.e-pics.ethz.ch/latelogin.jspx?records=:579552&r=1523389539059#1523389548982_1> with a CC BY-SA 4.0<https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/> licence. Because it is a CC share-alike licence, Kate would like to confirm with you if Jamal can use the image in the article if the entire article cannot be licenced CC BY-SA 4.0. Can the article be published with only the one image maintaining the CC BY-SA 4.0 license, and the rest of the article have the standard “all rights reserved” copyright protection? Thanks! Shelby Heather M. Ross (B.A., B.Ed., M.Ed.) Educational Developer (Digital Pedagogies) Gwenna Moss Centre for Teaching and Learning Research Fellow Open Education Group Room 50.5, Murray Building University of Saskatchewan Tel: 306.966.5327<tel:(306)%20966-5327> email: heather.ross(a)usask.ca<mailto:heather.ross(a)usask.ca> http://teaching.usask.ca/index.php Find open textbooks and other open educational resources on: http://open.usask.ca<http://open.usask.ca/> _______________________________________________ Canadaoer mailing list Canadaoer(a)mail.bccampus.ca<mailto:Canadaoer(a)mail.bccampus.ca> http://lists.bccampus.ca/mailman/listinfo/canadaoer
Also, What David said!! wouldn't it be nice if they followed the Tri-Council Policy... On Tue, 10 Apr 2018 at 17:07 Ross, Heather <heather.ross(a)usask.ca> wrote:
Thanks Kelsey.
Heather M. Ross (B.A., B.Ed., M.Ed.) Educational Developer (Digital Pedagogies) Gwenna Moss Centre for Teaching and Learning
Research Fellow Open Education Group
Room 50.5, Murray Building University of Saskatchewan Tel: 306.966.5327 <(306)%20966-5327> email: heather.ross(a)usask.ca <heather.ross(a)usask.ca> http://teaching.usask.ca/index.php
Find open textbooks and other open educational resources on: http://open.usask.ca
On Apr 10, 2018, at 3:06 PM, Kelsey Merkley <kelsey(a)uncommonwomen.org> wrote:
Hi Heather
The SA only kicks in if a derivative is made. The work has to be meaningful altered. If he's using the images as it - He can mark the image as CC BY-SA 4.0 with attribution and not impact his copyright
Kelsey
On Tue, 10 Apr 2018 at 16:59 Ross, Heather <heather.ross(a)usask.ca> wrote:
I received the following email from our copyright office today. My initial thought is he can’t use it in the journal article, but I want to confirm this. Thank you.
Hi Heather,
A researcher with Geological Sciences named Jamal came in the other day to ask Kate some questions about a paper he would like to publish. We aren’t certain, but we think he wants to publish in a traditional (i.e., not open) geology journal. He has pictures from five different sources he would like to include. Four are third-party images from already published books are journal article. The last image is a creative commons image <http://ba.e-pics.ethz.ch/latelogin.jspx?records=:579552&r=1523389539059#1523389548982_1> with a CC BY-SA 4.0 <https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/> licence.
Because it is a CC share-alike licence, Kate would like to confirm with you if Jamal can use the image in the article if the entire article cannot be licenced CC BY-SA 4.0. Can the article be published with only the one image maintaining the CC BY-SA 4.0 license, and the rest of the article have the standard “all rights reserved” copyright protection?
Thanks! Shelby
Heather M. Ross (B.A., B.Ed., M.Ed.) Educational Developer (Digital Pedagogies) Gwenna Moss Centre for Teaching and Learning
Research Fellow Open Education Group
Room 50.5, Murray Building University of Saskatchewan Tel: 306.966.5327 <(306)%20966-5327> email: heather.ross(a)usask.ca <heather.ross(a)usask.ca> http://teaching.usask.ca/index.php
Find open textbooks and other open educational resources on: http://open.usask.ca
_______________________________________________ Canadaoer mailing list Canadaoer(a)mail.bccampus.ca http://lists.bccampus.ca/mailman/listinfo/canadaoer
_______________________________________________ Canadaoer mailing list Canadaoer(a)mail.bccampus.ca http://lists.bccampus.ca/mailman/listinfo/canadaoer
I noted that in my response and that he should speak with his librarian who is an expert on open access publishing. Heather M. Ross (B.A., B.Ed., M.Ed.) Educational Developer (Digital Pedagogies) Gwenna Moss Centre for Teaching and Learning Research Fellow Open Education Group Room 50.5, Murray Building University of Saskatchewan Tel: 306.966.5327 email: heather.ross(a)usask.ca<mailto:heather.ross(a)usask.ca> http://teaching.usask.ca/index.php Find open textbooks and other open educational resources on: http://open.usask.ca On Apr 10, 2018, at 3:09 PM, Kelsey Merkley <kelsey(a)uncommonwomen.org<mailto:kelsey(a)uncommonwomen.org>> wrote: Also, What David said!! wouldn't it be nice if they followed the Tri-Council Policy... On Tue, 10 Apr 2018 at 17:07 Ross, Heather <heather.ross(a)usask.ca<mailto:heather.ross(a)usask.ca>> wrote: Thanks Kelsey. Heather M. Ross (B.A., B.Ed., M.Ed.) Educational Developer (Digital Pedagogies) Gwenna Moss Centre for Teaching and Learning Research Fellow Open Education Group Room 50.5, Murray Building University of Saskatchewan Tel: 306.966.5327<tel:(306)%20966-5327> email: heather.ross(a)usask.ca<mailto:heather.ross(a)usask.ca> http://teaching.usask.ca/index.php Find open textbooks and other open educational resources on: http://open.usask.ca<http://open.usask.ca/> On Apr 10, 2018, at 3:06 PM, Kelsey Merkley <kelsey(a)uncommonwomen.org<mailto:kelsey(a)uncommonwomen.org>> wrote: Hi Heather The SA only kicks in if a derivative is made. The work has to be meaningful altered. If he's using the images as it - He can mark the image as CC BY-SA 4.0 with attribution and not impact his copyright Kelsey On Tue, 10 Apr 2018 at 16:59 Ross, Heather <heather.ross(a)usask.ca<mailto:heather.ross(a)usask.ca>> wrote: I received the following email from our copyright office today. My initial thought is he can’t use it in the journal article, but I want to confirm this. Thank you. Hi Heather, A researcher with Geological Sciences named Jamal came in the other day to ask Kate some questions about a paper he would like to publish. We aren’t certain, but we think he wants to publish in a traditional (i.e., not open) geology journal. He has pictures from five different sources he would like to include. Four are third-party images from already published books are journal article. The last image is a creative commons image<http://ba.e-pics.ethz.ch/latelogin.jspx?records=:579552&r=1523389539059#1523389548982_1> with a CC BY-SA 4.0<https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/> licence. Because it is a CC share-alike licence, Kate would like to confirm with you if Jamal can use the image in the article if the entire article cannot be licenced CC BY-SA 4.0. Can the article be published with only the one image maintaining the CC BY-SA 4.0 license, and the rest of the article have the standard “all rights reserved” copyright protection? Thanks! Shelby Heather M. Ross (B.A., B.Ed., M.Ed.) Educational Developer (Digital Pedagogies) Gwenna Moss Centre for Teaching and Learning Research Fellow Open Education Group Room 50.5, Murray Building University of Saskatchewan Tel: 306.966.5327<tel:(306)%20966-5327> email: heather.ross(a)usask.ca<mailto:heather.ross(a)usask.ca> http://teaching.usask.ca/index.php Find open textbooks and other open educational resources on: http://open.usask.ca<http://open.usask.ca/> _______________________________________________ Canadaoer mailing list Canadaoer(a)mail.bccampus.ca<mailto:Canadaoer(a)mail.bccampus.ca> http://lists.bccampus.ca/mailman/listinfo/canadaoer _______________________________________________ Canadaoer mailing list Canadaoer(a)mail.bccampus.ca<mailto:Canadaoer(a)mail.bccampus.ca> http://lists.bccampus.ca/mailman/listinfo/canadaoer
participants (3)
-
David Porter -
Kelsey Merkley -
Ross, Heather